Nov 15, 2023 02:18:11 pm
Manhajul Islam, S. Ak - BATS Consulting
In a recent United Nations
meeting, the European Union (EU) and the United Kingdom (UK) have come under
scrutiny for allegedly attempting to thwart proposals aimed at granting
developing countries a greater voice in international tax discussions.
Countries at the UN are
currently engaged in discussions on plans to enhance the role of the UN in
global tax deliberations—a proposition driven by low and middle-income nations.
For decades, the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD)
has served as the platform for countries to engage in international tax
discussions. However, some developing nations feel that this system does not
adequately represent their interests.
Last year, a coalition of
54 African nations, frustrated with the OECD, successfully brought a resolution
to the UN. The resolution suggested that the UN Secretary-General produce a
report to strengthen international tax cooperation, including granting a more
substantial role to the UN.
Despite the production of
this report, representatives from the EU and the UK are reportedly opposing all
options presented. Negotiators from developing countries have expressed that
"they do not want to bring tax matters to the UN. They are attempting to
halt this process."
Developing countries,
including Nigeria, Ghana, India, and Brazil, advocate for a binding legal role
for the UN in tax discussions. However, the EU is concerned that the UN could
disrupt existing procedures at the OECD, potentially causing turmoil in the
international tax system. In 2021, the OECD attempted to address corporate tax
avoidance, but implementation faced delays.
In September, EU finance
ministers suggested that EU member states "could consider working in the
UN on a voluntary multilateral agenda." Nevertheless, EU representatives
appear unsupportive of the voluntary options proposed in the UN Secretary-Generals
report.
Instead, they advocate for
the creation of a new working group that will propose alternative options for
the UNs role. This group will discuss these new options at the 80th UN General
Assembly in September 2025. Negotiators from developing countries deem this
suggestion "unproductive and aimed at delaying decisions."
A spokesperson for the UK
government stated that the UK has "long collaborated with international
partners on tax matters" and has a "strong track record" of
working with developing countries. Despite differences of opinion, both parties
claim to be negotiating in good faith.